Missing roof shingles: repair or replace?

Missing shingles aren't an automatic replace call. How to read the pattern and write up a repair-vs-replace roof finding.

Steven Meng-Huan Tsai
AuthorSteven Meng-Huan TsaiLicensed Professional Engineer (Civil) in California, Texas and Nevada. I've done structural inspections on many homes as a licensed engineer, and I build report software for home inspectors.
Published
Read5 min read
Photo of an asphalt shingle roof with shingles missing.

Photo: Sandul1234, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped

A buyer under contract on a house about ten years old asked about it on r/HomeInspections after the inspection found missing asphalt shingles. A relative who inspects had warned that shingles can't be fixed one at a time. The gap alone does not decide repair or replace; the roof around it does.

The post's first photo shows the inspector's report, which rated the roof covering poor: damaged and missing shingles on the south slope, exposed nail heads at a roof vent's flashing that should be sealed, and signs of impact damage and possible earlier ice damming in a valley. It recommended a roofing contractor. In the report's two roof photos, the problem shingles sit in short runs next to the vents near the ridge.

A patched repair that looks right versus one that doesn't

Photo: see the original post on r/HomeInspections.

Commenters read the photos differently. One saw damage from people walking on hot shingles, two unsealed fasteners and a few shingles to replace in two areas near the ridge. That commenter also said a good roofer can replace a single shingle. Another said the shingles looked good and only the damaged ones needed repair. A third said to replace the roof because water had already got in. The buyer added that the kickout flashing was not installed properly. Two of the commenters said the call needs someone on the roof.

Side-by-side drawing: a patch among bare, lifted and curled shingles with exposed nails and sealant daubs, next to a matching replacement shingle with covered nails, a bonded seal strip and flat neighbouring tabs.
Fig. 1Same repair, different surroundings: what the inspector reads around a replaced shingle.

A spot repair is only as sound as the shingles it ties into. If the replacement lies flat, lines up with its course and the neighbors still seal down, the gap reads as a local event. Among lifted tabs, exposed fasteners and old sealant daubs, it is one symptom of a wider problem.

What to check when shingles are missing

  1. Where the loss sits: one slope or edge, or scattered across the roof.
  2. The shingles next to the gap: granule cover, flat sealed tabs, or curling, cracking and lifting edges.
  3. Fasteners: nail heads on the exposed face, nails backing out, or sealant smeared over them.
  4. Earlier repairs, such as mismatched shingles or several patches in one area.
  5. The attic deck under the area, if accessible, for staining.
Flowchart from missing shingles through five checks: loss in one area, tabs flat and sealed, granules intact, exposed nails, earlier patches. Any warning sign leads to a full review by a roofer; none leads to a likely spot repair.
Fig. 2Any one warning sign moves the finding from a repair note toward a roofer's full review.

Missing shingles do not prove poor installation by themselves. That call needs the nailing checked directly, and lifting sealed tabs to look is usually the roofer's job.

What can change the callMore detail

Loss limited to one area, with sound and well-sealed shingles around it, leans toward a spot repair.

Shingles that crack when a roofer lifts them to slip in a replacement can turn a small repair into a larger job. That is one reason the roofer makes the repair-or-replace decision after handling the material.

A replacement shingle in a different color is cosmetic on its own. Note it if the buyer is likely to care.

Staining on the attic deck under the area changes the finding. It is no longer only about the roof covering, and the comment should say so.

Why this goes in the report

An open spot leaves the underlayment as the only layer between the weather and the deck. The buyer can act on that before closing, so it belongs in the report.

One clustered loss on sound shingles reads as a repair item. Scattered loss, brittle or bare shingles, or stacked patches make it a referral: a licensed roofing contractor evaluates the whole roof covering and says whether it can take spot repairs. Roof age is context. The surface cannot confirm a remaining-life number, so leave it out.

Photos to takeMore detail
  • A wide shot of each slope, so the reader can see where the loss sits on the roof.
  • A close-up of the gap with the underlayment or deck visible.
  • The shingles next to the gap: tab edges, seal line and granule surface.
  • Any exposed or backed-out fasteners and any sealant over nails.
  • Each earlier patch, with enough of the slope to show how many there are.
  • The attic deck under the area, if accessible.
Limits of this callMore detail

This is general guidance for writing up a finding. It is not roofing or engineering advice for a specific property, and it gives no cost and no remaining-life estimate.

Check your own SOP for what your scope requires on roof coverings and on walking the roof. Defer to a licensed roofing contractor on repair method and on whether the roof should be replaced.

How this goes in Morph

Four steps in a row: Snap a photo of the gap, Speak a voice note on the pattern, Generate the narrative, then the inspector reviews and signs. Capture works with no signal.
Fig. 3Snap, Speak, Generate, then the inspector reviews and signs.

In Morph, this finding takes three steps: Snap a photo of the gap, Speak a voice note on the pattern, and Generate, where Morph writes the narrative on the spot in your own style. Capture works with no signal, and AI drafting runs when you're back online. Morph drafts and organizes, you review and decide, and nothing is sent without your approval. Your photos, voice notes, comments and wording are used only to write your own reports; Morph never uses them to train its AI and never shares them with or uses them for anyone else. Try the free plan on your next roof finding, and if it is not a good fit, that is fine too.

More videos and reading